new idea [comment on image]

[Mr_LovaLove]

is it possible to have something like comment on image or i can say new level ( let assume : commenter )

like www.shutterpoint.com

and under every image there is something like:

1- Composition: bad - good -excellent
2- Creativity / Originality: bad - good -excellent
3-  Depth of Field / Focus: bad - good -excellent
4-Color or Tonal Range: bad - good -excellent
5- Noise or Grain: bad - good -excellent
6- Exposure / Lighting: bad - good -excellent
7- Tells a Story: bad - good -excellent
8-  Dramatic Effect: bad - good -excellent
and eveyone has it own percentages

after the vote the total number of % appears to the user

or let say it could be set somewhere in the details page

the user levels could be like:

- new level for commenter
- all members
- all visitors

seems great !

be free to add and talk and share and help and hope to code :p

[mawenzi]

... interesting ... and you have users, to fill such forms ... ?
... but it seems, that only registered users can vote on shutterpoint.com ... so I don't see the voting form ...
... and if you would have such a voting system on your 4images gallery, I think you need ...

- Additional image fields for every voting point (total) ... (in your case 8 ...) ...
  http://www.4homepages.de/forum/index.php?topic=20748.0

- Dropdown options for custom database fields
  http://www.4homepages.de/forum/index.php?topic=7112.0
  or
  Ajax Star Rating
  http://www.4homepages.de/forum/index.php?topic=17829.0
  or
  A java script, that calculate total voting ...
  then you don't need additional image fields ...

- a formula to calculate the total voting ... e.g.
  ... composition (criterion_composition) = 12.5% of total voting
  ... ... bad (criterion_composition_voting) = 0% of total composition
  ... ... good (criterion_composition_voting) = 50% of total composition
  ... ... excellent (criterion_composition_voting) = 100% of total composition
  ... a.s.o. ...
  ... and your formula e.g. :
  ... total_voting = (criterion_composition x criterion_composition_voting) + (criterion_creativity x criterion_creativity_voting) + ... a.s.o. ...

- additional image field for saving of total_voting ... (in your case 1 ...) ...
  http://www.4homepages.de/forum/index.php?topic=20748.0

- and some html-design-snippets for presenting of total_voting on details page ...

- and what I've still forgotten ... ?

As i said ... interesting ... but I don't have such users ... 

[Mr_LovaLove]

@mawenzi

thanks alot for the nice replay

yes for me i have pro photographers who will be assigned to vote for the images

in fact, this help my users to know how much they improve

i will try to make it and tell u the result

maybe it can be added to 4image ! maybe not ! its all about the needs