... the "comment counter" ... we are on the right way ...
... the counter should display "Nr.1" for the first comment and e.g. "Nr.615" for the latest comment ...
... your counter code display display "Nr.615" for the first comment and "Nr.1" for the latest comment ...
... so I try the following counter code with success and without the bug Sun has shown ...
$comment_counter = $num_rows_all-($offset+$i);... thanks V@no for your right hint ...
... I've updated the first MOD-post ... it's now "All Comments Version 1.6" ...